- Welsh Professor and former Scottish Government Minister call for “radical rethink”
- Huw Morris and Des McNulty call for rethink of purpose and functioning of Colleges and Universities
- New government review a “missed opportunity”
Huw Morris, a UCL Professor of Tertiary Education on secondment from the Welsh Government, and Des McNulty, former Minister for Social Justice in the Scottish Government, today call for a radical rethink of the purpose and functioning of Scotland’s tertiary education sector.
In a paper for the independent think tank Enlighten, they argue that both parts of the system – colleges and universities – must be rethought together by a formal Commission.
In the paper – Where next for Scottish Universities and Colleges? – Morris and McNulty argue that:
- Funding for Scottish students is defective and unsustainable
- The reluctance to charge tuition fees to Scottish students leads to the expansion in recruitment of foreign students, and to the expansion of courses which are less costly to teach
- Scottish students are finding it increasingly difficult to be admitted to the three ‘elite’ Scottish universities because these universities are penalised for taking them
- Scottish higher education is expensive because of the four-year degree, compared to the equivalent three-year degree at English universities
They also suggest that:
- System failure is most acute in the College sector, with 92% of Colleges in deficit
- Colleges can be penalised for attempting to react to the unmet needs of the employment market
Commenting, Huw Morris, Honorary Professor of Tertiary Education at the Institute of Education, UCL’s Faculty of Education and Society said:
“The near collapse at the University of Dundee ought to have been a crystallising event, generating discussion about hard choices on university funding – not just about its scale and who pays but also the objectives of public funding.
“Instead, the Scottish Government battened down the hatches, offering money it previously argued wasn’t there to keep Dundee University afloat, while an inquiry focused on internal arrangements, avoiding looking at other actors and wider issues affecting the sector.
“Scotland can no longer afford to avoid hard questions. It is now well-established that colleges are on a financial and operational cliff-edge, but the reality is that universities’dependence on overseas markets means that they are also one sudden shock away from an existential problem.
Commenting on the Scottish Government’s new Framework for Sustainability and Success of Scotland’s Universities review, Huw Morris said:
“It is regrettable that the remit of the review does not provide a forum for the necessary broader public debate about the future of post-school education, looking at the funding of colleges alongside that of universities, and assessing what the tertiary system does and does not contribute to national and regional development. This seems like a missed opportunity.”
Des McNulty, Chair of the Advisory Board at the Local Policy Innovation Partnership Hub at the University of Birmingham and former Scottish Government Minister for Social Justice, added:
“Scotland has a skills crisis. We can resolve it, but only if the tertiary sector collaborates to reduce barriers and focuses on working with regional partners, including employers, to identify areas of economic growth potential and meet current and future skills needs.
“To get there, we need a broad public debate about the future of post-school education, including its funding and what the current system does and does not contribute to national and regional development.
“Nothing should be off the table.”
Chris Deerin, Director of Enlighten, said:
“Des McNulty and Huw Morris have given us a very stark warning that kicking the problem into the long grass will only worsen the crisis. Colleges and universities are an essential part of Scottish life and it is time to think afresh. Like Enlighten, McNulty and Morris recognise the current system is unsustainable. It’s beyond time politicians started listening.”
ENDS
NOTES TO EDITORS
- The report – Where next for Scottish Universities and Colleges? – can be read here.
- Enlighten is a public policy institute which works to promote increased economic prosperity, opportunity for all, and more effective public services. Enlighten is independent of political parties and any other organisations. It is funded by donations from private individuals, charitable trusts and corporate organisations. Its Director is Chris Deerin and Alison Payne is the Research Director. Both work closely with the Trustee Board, chaired by Lord McConnell, which meets regularly to review the research and policy programme.
- For Enlighten media contact Andy Maciver, [email protected], 07855 261 244
