Introduction
The following sets out a proposed way forward for the development of an effective strategy for NHS Scotland. Elsewhere it has been argued that the characteristics of the way health strategies in Scotland have been formulated has worked against achieving sustainable major (strategic) changes to fundamental the balance of care and resource distribution to health services. This has been the case dating back to the 1980s. [1] The main characteristics relevant here have been:
- A lack of strategic capacity and skills within the health service in Scotland.
- Very extensive stakeholder engagement in formulating strategies that has tended to produce gradual, marginal changes.
- Strategies overly driven by short term financial constraints rather than properly planned long-term investment which reduces and delays the impact of strategies. [2]
- The objectives within strategies are not adequately developed – too many, unresolved conflicting aims, insufficiently measurable, lack of clear timescales, not supported by complementary delivery plans.
- Underdeveloped resource planning (money, people, estates, equipment, new technology) that effectively leaves strategies incomplete when they are launched.
In considering strategic change, it is also worth taking account of the wider financial circumstances facing health services in Scotland. In 1999-2000 real terms health spending per person in Scotland was £1,897. By 2010-11 it was £3,089, an average annual growth rate of c6% over the decade. In 2019-20 spending per head had grown to £3,223, a real terms growth rate of just 0.4% over that decade. By 2024-25 real terms spending per person had reached £3,644, meaning an average growth over that five-year of c2%. [3] Since the 2010s funding of the NHS has in no way matched previous levels of uplift and with it fallen well short of meeting the higher inflation levels that the NHS faces (increasing unit costs, utilisation rates (ageing population) and innovations) that it needs just to stand still. Performance has suffered significantly, which was also exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic.
The result is that a major strategic issue now facing the NHS is that of recovery. This involves filling service gaps such as waiting times that result from funding not matching historic levels. A critical aspect of this is that the resulting pressure to recover ‘lost performance’ is not seen as a strategic challenge but one for short-term fixes. The consequences of remaining stuck with possibly outdated service models needs serious consideration. Increasingly politicians, those within the health service and commentators have promoted finding innovative solutions as a way to address financial sustainability and address performance problems. This should be treated with some caution. Innovations can improve effectiveness and efficiency but, while some will result in lower costs, others will increase them, particularly upfront costs. Nonetheless, with that qualification, a general theme of what is set out here is that more must be done to drive innovation, particularly its implementation and adoption. However, at present it is not clear from where innovation is being driven. It is hoped that proposals set out here will bring innovation more to the fore. There will however have to be serious consideration given to increasing the flow of innovative ideas for developing strategy. In this regard, it is important to stress that innovation is a term which should not be seen solely in terms of technological advance. Innovation can also apply to the way services are organised, including models of staffing.
Discussions of reform and the transformation of the NHS have to some extent started to be drawn into reviewing the funding model of the NHS. There is no escaping the comparatively low levels of health funding in the UK/Scotland which prompts consideration of the funding model. To increase funding, it is necessary to recognises that there is no simple solution, and a significant part of the population would have to increase their contribution to health spend, whether through general taxation or another mechanism. (It is possible that health spend could be increased by reducing other heads of expenditure, but this seems to be not very likely.) Alternative models of funding would potentially offer more expensive ways of fund the NHS than that of taxpayer funding. Suggestions such as charging for services like GP appointments will raise relatively limited funds, be comparatively expensive to implement, could discourage service uptake and lead in an unconsidered, creeping way to change the fundamental nature of the NHS. The funding model of the NHS raises major issues with no straightforward answers or grounds for agreement. For purposes of this paper, therefore, seeking reform of the funding system is seen as an entirely separate exercise from adopting different organisational and resource arrangements for the delivery of health services. The positive news is that strategic change can significantly help cost pressures by introducing/extending models of services that represent more cost-effective ways of delivering the care and health support people need.
Taking Health Strategy Forward: An Outline Proposal
The argument here is that a strong health strategy requires a robust process of development. The process should not be over-complicated but should offer opportunities to consider in-depth the quality of evidence underpinning what will deliver the results that the NHS in Scotland needs. This should draw upon those with the necessary knowledge, expertise and experience rather than those simply holding particular senior positions within health organisations who often have a strongly operational outlook.
Much of the evidence required for securing effective strategies is already available and the real challenge is to marshal it in a way that can guide change through the various health and care bodies responsible for organising and delivering services, not least in ways helpful to these organisations. This means specifying at a high-level concrete changes to the way services are organised and resourced, and what these changes aim to achieve. It is additionally about avoiding statements overly based on aspirations and political messaging.
Developing a single integrated health strategy could however prove too complex to organise and to produce. The development of strategy should therefore proceed under a number of different topic headings around discrete service areas. A suggested list of topics for further discussion is set out below. Each contains a broad statement of intent summarising the overarching changes sought. Further service areas could be added such as the geographic distribution of highly specialist medical and surgical services, reducing the incidence of mental health presentations and offering health improvement interventions to counter the impacts of poverty. Maternity care may also be one that needs strategic change rather than simply being seen to be about raising operational quality. The current list of topics put forward are for further discussion are:
- The creation of a properly constituted primary care-led health service integrated with social care that offers proactive care, acts to keep people well, makes sure people’s care and support is effectively coordinated, and appropriately maximises the amount of care people receive outside a secondary hospital setting supporting their health and well-being.
- The organisation of acute emergency hospital care to allow for the appropriate level of admissions related to clinical need and achieving a faster but safe throughput.
- The necessary funding to match growing demands for elective hospital care, along with improvements to increase efficiency and to offer a consistently better experience for users.
- The design and consistent adoption of models for mental health care that reduce over-dependence on crisis driven services, improve community support and offer more responsive emergency services.
- The more clearly defined and practical role for the NHS, councils and voluntary organisations in improving the health of the population, particularly as it concerns those living in deprived circumstances.
To take matters forward it is proposed that a ‘Strategic Support Group’ (SSG) is established that would oversee and support the setting up of Service Strategy Forums (SSFs) that will directly produce a strategic statement for each of the service areas identified above. The SSG will do four things. Firstly, to help select the members for each SSF taking into account the independence, strategic outlook, familiarity with relevant evidence and the specific areas of expertise of members. Secondly, to support each SSF to produce a terms of reference along with an agreed plan of work focused upon what needs to be done and by when. Thirdly, to devise a general template for the presentation of service strategies for all SSFs that will offer service delivery organisations a clear set of actions and outcomes that they can pursue, to be adjusted for what they have already achieved. Finally, to advise on creating a broad case that supports the strategies produced by the SSFs. This is very much about promoting the case for the strategies to the wider health service, including an assessment of the likely negative implications for health outcomes and service sustainability if the service models are not adopted along the lines set out in strategy. The core of the work of the SSFs is to produce a strategic statement that that contains service models [4] that offer significantly improved outcomes for people in line with the broad changes set out in each SSF’s remit. The strategic statement should also address relative cost-benefit ratios of different service models, the strength of the evidence available, how quickly suggested changes can be implemented, the scale of risks associated with introducing the changes and the wider resource requirements of moving forward with changed service models.
A strategic statement should contain the following:
- The critical components of the service model and what are the important interrelationships between the components that can deliver improved benefits for those for whom the service is intended. (Components are aspects of the service – location(s), assessment, interventions, review, discharge arrangements, roles and responsibilities of staff groups.)
- The characteristic(s) of those people who it is intended should benefit from the service.
- The means by which people can access the service.
- The criteria to be met by individuals to be eligible to receive the service.
- The criteria for people being discharged from the service (including transfer to another service).
- The profile of the changed requirements and cost impact for:
- staffing
- estates and facilities
- equipment
- new technology solutions
- A statement of the principal benefits for adopting the changed service model.
- A statement of the important risks to achieving the principal benefits.
- An assessment of the quality of evidence supporting adoption/extension of service model.
- A summary of the case for adoption of the service model, including any qualifications and reservations.
Discussion
There is a danger that what is set out above gives the impression of strategy development by numbers. What in fact is being proposed is something quite different. It is designed to set out the essence of a strategic plan based around models of service. This requires defining precisely what the major strategic changes proposed are and the grounds upon which they are put forward. It will need to be understandable on a consistent basis by those working in health services, which requires using hard statements that are clear and not open to variable interpretations. It should be much more like a technical specification, much less statements of context and ambitions. Crafting the correct wording will be an essential requirement, as will having communications and engagement plans to connect the strategic and operational parts together.
The strategic statement should only offer a high-level overview of how a service is to be organised in the future. The strategic plan can then be picked up by an operational service, developed into detailed operational plans which when implemented lead to significant service change. There is no straightforward way to distinguish between strategic and operational plans in that the distinction is relative, but where the division should lie is an explicit consideration for the development of the strategy. The aim should be to keep strategy precise and clear, while also ensuring the operational parts of the health system have considerable freedom to produce operational plans that can address local circumstances.
Once a strategic statement has been produced, an SSF should promote the statement to a diverse audience engaging with those who have familiarity with the relevant user population and current services. This is to allow for a ‘road-testing’ of the strategic statements allowing opportunities to improve them, make them more attuned to a smoother and quicker implementation and give them a wider endorsement that forms part of decisions about formal adoption as well as offering opportunities to improve the service models.
The approach here quite consciously aims to see an overall reduction in the extent to which internal and external political considerations draw strategy making away from more optimal solutions. A national strategic system must be guided by an emphasis upon the collective national benefit including funding. Politics ultimately is critical to a publicly funded service, but many politicians make a virtue out of what James Mitchel calls the Narcissism of Small Differences. [5] Likewise, different professional groupings are well organised in emphasising professional interests over any possible wider public interest in the longer-term direction of the NHS. And finally, the Scottish Government places great store in maintaining support for its guardianship of the NHS which means hard, but unpopular, choices are moderated or avoided. The part these organisations play in strategy formulation needs revisiting.
It is important to stress that pursuing the above will require certain important matters to be dealt with at an early stage. Firstly, there will need to be consideration of how the strategic capacity is built and populated by the right people. This also must include addressing how they enjoy sufficient autonomy such that strategy development is not excessively driven at an early stage by political considerations at the expense of evidence based problem-solving. Secondly, any attempt to be more radically strategic increases political risks. This will have to be handled with openness and sensitivity but should also involve consideration of the explicit trade-offs between building sustainability for the NHS and responding to calls for safer, incremental change. Strategy development requires more consideration of critical trade-offs. Thirdly, any new strategy will require operational units and frontline staff to align what they do to the strategic framework adopted. It is important that there are open and strong channels for discussion among the three functions of front line, operational and strategic to consider how this can happen in a way respectful of the different challenges each faces in pursuing major change.
Peter Williamson taught and researched health care policy and management at Aberdeen Medical School, was a strategy director for NHS Boards, and led policy work on health and innovation for the Scottish Government.
[1] Peter Williamson ‘Reforming Health And Care In Scotland: Getting Strategy Right By Being Properly Strategic’ , Enlighten Scotland, NHS 2048, 9 October 2025/ (https://www.enlighten.scot/reforming-health-and-care-in-scotland-getting-strategy-right-by-being-properly-strategic-peter-williamson/)
[2] The alternative is to pursue fewer strategies but invest in a way that matches the challenges faced.
[3] Martin Brogaard, et al, Public service spending and performance in Scotland, Institute of Fiscal Studies Report, 2026, 10.
[4] A model of service consists of a number of components making up the design of a health service that exists to respond to one or more health needs of individuals. The model will cover how people access the service, what selection criteria are used, the actual processes of care, transfer and handover within a service, and discharge from the service along with how those providing care are organised and the different roles and responsibilities they have. The actual design of a service incorporates theories of care/interventions/ practice, evidence-based practices, common standards, professional guidance, and values and norms generally found in the health system. For reasons of limiting the number of models contained within a strategic statement to make it manageable, there may have to be some editing of what is included. This decision should rest with the SSF taking account of the opportunities for substantial improvement, cost of the current service(s) and the size of the cohort of those who should benefit. Where there for example are well-established pathways for conditions such as diabetes mellitus and fractures, they might be excluded because the room for improvement is limited.
[5] James Mitchell ‘The Narcissism of Small Differences: Scotland and Westminster, Parliamentary Affairs 63(1) (2010): 98-116.
