Opens in a new tab

The election is an opportunity to prioritise working together for the long-term future of the NHS – Mark Strachan

The NHS is an organisation about which I care very deeply. I have worked continuously in the NHS in Scotland since 1992. I have never practiced in the private medicine sector. I believe fundamentally in the principle of a health service that is free to all at the point of care. In my NHS clinic, I see all too often people from different parts of the world – where private medicine is a feature – who have been subjected to needless, expensive investigations for no reason, other than that they are items of service that can be charged for by their respective healthcare service. These investigations often turn up ‘incidental’ findings that will not reduce the quality or length of life of that individual, but which catalyse even more investigation and sometimes unnecessary treatment.

The NHS in Scotland is not without its faults, but a basic and unshakeable tenet is that the investigations performed and the treatments offered are done so in the best interests of the patient, albeit in a cost-effective manner that is for the good of the whole of society.

Being such a passionate supporter of the NHS, it is a source of genuine and considerable pain to see the gradual decline in the service it provides. There is no doubt that in times of extreme need, the NHS will be there to provide some of the best and most innovative care in the world. However, the difficulties people have in seeing a GP, the long waiting times for elective surgery, diagnostic investigations and out-patient appointments are both distressing for patients and distressing for staff.

Elective waiting lists continue to face sustained pressure, with an estimated 504,949 ongoing waits for a new outpatient appointment as at 31 January 2026. Long waits of more than 52 weeks also persist, including 30,259 waits for an outpatient appointment, underscoring the scale of the challenge against the Scottish Government’s pledge to eliminate waits longer than 12 months by March 2026.

Long waits in emergency departments and caring for patients in corridors have become normalised. Recruitment and retention of medical staff in some parts of Scotland is an enormous challenge, while rota gaps and sickness absence amongst the medical workforce are now commonplace. As people live longer, medicines become more expensive and the breadth of treatable conditions expands, the costs of healthcare will relentlessly rise and given the understandable constraints on government funding, it is plausible that the performance of our NHS will continue to decline.

The Scottish Parliament election on 7th May is pivotal for our NHS, and as we have indicated in our own “health manifesto”, politicians from all parties must use this as an opportunity to be up-front and honest with the public about the challenges it faces as part of a long promised “national conversation”. No one political party can claim to have all of the solutions. The national conversation could come in the form of a National Convention, which would include service users (the general public), the healthcare professions and politicians.

We therefore urge the next Scottish Government – whatever its complexion – to create a Convention before the end of 2026. The harsh reality is that we cannot fund all healthcare for everyone in Scotland, all of the time, without NHS reform. That reform can only be achieved with cross-party support in the next Scottish Parliament. Without such cross-party support the NHS is unlikely to survive in its current form.

Scotland does not have to look far to find examples of such political consensus. In November 2024, the Danish Government announced a political agreement on healthcare reform, backed by a broad coalition of the three governing parties (the Social Democratic Party, the Liberal Party, and the Moderates) and four additional parties from across the political spectrum.

The agreement included general practice reform; chronic care packages for COPD, diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and patients with complex multimorbidity; a national agency to oversee digital health, data infrastructure and innovation projects; and a new national public health law.

Cross-party political agreement on NHS reform is possible. NHS staff are often told they must change their ways of working to improve quality of service. The same is now true of our politicians. Scotland’s political parties must use the election as a chance to prioritise working together for the long-term future of the NHS. Ultimately, we need a plan for reform backed by investment. If the funding envelope available cannot be increased, the “free at the point of use” NHS founding principle is seriously at risk.

In our health manifesto for the election, we present some ideas for reform. For example, we call for action on delayed discharges, to reduce pressure on hospital bed capacity and ensure that people are getting care where they need it most; and a medical workforce plan designed to attract more people to study medicine and stay in Scotland to practice it. Furthermore, we want to see investment in, and integration of, adult social care; action to address the current negative trends around life expectancy and the persistent health inequalities in Scotland and to ensure that the NHS is part of the tech revolution while improving current IT systems to reduce technological barriers for our hard-working people.

Finally, it is worth noting that Scotland can take lessons from the Darzi report, published in September 2024, which outlined three strategic shifts towards futureproofing the NHS in England: from hospital to community, from analogue to digital and from sickness to prevention. The College agrees with this approach and we have consistently urged the NHS in Scotland to follow suit. Many of our policy recommendations are focused around these three ambitions, indicating how seriously we take them. Scotland’s political parties should take them seriously, too. The Health and Social Care Renewal Framework, published by the Scottish Government in June 2025, is a step in the right direction towards following the Darzi ‘three strategic shifts’ and we are encouraging the Scottish Government – whatever its complexion after the election – to continue down this route.

Remarkable innovation is happening across Scotland’s health and care sectors, led by talented and ambitious clinicians, academics and researchers. Our workforce can be empowered and they want to help lead change, but this can only happen if Scotland’s political parties work together to match these ambitions.

Professor Mark Strachan is President of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh

Got something to say about this? Leave your comment below. Comments may be moderated before displaying. By posting you agree to abide by our Terms and conditions. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed