A recent blog post by Paul Argyle McDonald regarding the mathematics curriculum in Scotland got me thinking about how the physics curriculum and its assessment, particularly in relation to Higher and Advanced Higher, has changed over the years. For context, I began teaching in 1984 just after a new Higher Physics syllabus had been introduced, replacing the one I had studied myself as a pupil in the late-1970s. I have taught all four of the iterations since, and for around fifteen years from the mid-1990s was involved in the teams responsible for setting most of the Higher and CSYS/Advanced Higher Physics examination papers. I was also a member of the Higher Still group for physics responsible for rewriting the curriculum and assessment arrangements in the late-1990s and am now on the Core Group for the sciences as part of the current Curriculum Improvement Cycle. Alongside this, throughout my career I have been active in subject associations responding to consultations and trying to influence change, something central to my current role at the Institute of Physics for which I have worked for the last few years since leaving the classroom.
So, how do I consider the curriculum and its assessment to have changed during my career? Firstly, not everything has changed, much of the content of the Higher Physics curriculum has remained largely the same during the last forty years. If one looks at examination papers from the 1980s, many of the topics assessed will be familiar to current school pupils – linear mechanics, resistive and capacitive circuits, wave refraction and interference – topics which are the bedrock of high school physics courses the world over. Some things have changed, the analogue electronics first introduced in the 1980s was replaced with cosmology and particle physics in the Revised Higher Physics syllabus introduced in the years immediately before the introduction of Curriculum for Excellence. Study of the Gas Laws has flitted back and forwards between Ordinary Grade to Higher and back to National 5. However, broadly speaking, I consider the content of the various Higher physics syllabi to have remained fairly similar in content and level.
Second, the balance of the sorts of questions asked in examinations such as Higher Physics has remained similar over the years. The classification and nomenclature used has evolved with each wave of curriculum and assessment reform but the procedures to ensure the balance of questions in examination papers between what I was mostly used to calling Knowledge and Understanding, Problem Solving, Problem Solving Plus have remained fairly similar. In short, I would describe Knowledge and Understanding questions as ones involving the fairly straightforward recall of information, Problem Solving to use simple calculations, data analysis etc. in respect to commonly encountered content within the course, and Problem Solving Plus to involve more complex questions requiring multi-stage calculations or dealing with contexts that are likely to be less familiar to candidates. I consider the balance between these sorts of questions in examinations to have remained fairly stable over time together with the fact that questions have frequently been set in real-world situations and applications. In this respect I consider the Scottish physics examinations to be better than many I have seen from other jurisdictions around the world.
The first main difference was that Curriculum for Excellence introduced an externally assessed assignment to Higher Physics for the first time alongside the examination. There had been practical abilities assessment as part of Standard Grade and a project in CSYS/Advanced Higher since their inception but no externally assessed practical work in Higher Physics. The nature of the assignment in Higher Physics has been problematic. An assignment with an externally assessed mark that contributes to the final grade has increased the stakes and stress on pupils and teachers, especially as there has been from the outset a lack of clarity about how the assignment should be conducted. The assignment has certainly taken up valuable class time which could have been spent more beneficially and ironically may well have decreased the quantity and quality of the practical work experience for many pupils. The assessment of practical work could take up a whole blog post of its own and I would like to focus here on the examinations which still contributes to the majority of a candidate’s grade in Higher Physics.
The main difference between the examinations for the courses I taught early in my career and those now has been the disappearance of option topics and question choice in the examinations. This means that all pupils now study a common course, and teachers are required to teach all topics. When I first started teaching CSYS Physics, pupils only had to answer a selection of five questions from a choice of twelve in the examination paper. This meant that more than six topics were rarely taught in many schools and some of the less popular topics, and those perceived as more difficult, such as electromagnetism, were only studied by a very small proportion of those studying the course. The experiences of pupils could be very different, something that is not so likely now. I consider the move to a common course for all to be generally beneficial, and not just for the examiners who no longer have to standardise marks over different topics and questions. Everyone can now be much more certain of what someone with a pass in Higher or Advanced Higher Physics has actually studied than was the case prior to Higher Still.
However, the content of the syllabus is not the only thing to consider when reflecting on educational standards over time. How have the examinations changed, and how have the marking procedures? Here there have been several changes over the forty plus years of my career. Early in my career, many examination questions consisted of several sentences of prose asking several questions for a block of perhaps 5, 6 or more marks. Examination papers were made more accessible to candidates by separating these out into parts (a) (i), (a) (ii), (b) etc. with a mark allocated to each. The questions being asked did not change, but it made the process of answering them more straightforward. I think this was an improvement in readability and not a dumbing down of the physics and generally beneficial for all.
Another change in the early-2000s was the introduction of a ‘relationships sheet’ with the relevant equations for each course. This was done to emphasise the application of knowledge rather than rote learning of the equations, however, I have always argued that for candidates to use the relationship sheet they basically need to know the equations anyway as they are listed with no annotation or explanation. The relationship sheet should be considered more of a ‘safety net’ for use in the heat of the examination room than something which should be relied upon at all times.
More recently, for administrative reasons, in order to remove the need for half marks, especially in numerical calculations, the marks allocated to questions were changed. This generally led to examination papers having more marks than previously. It also led to the overall mark for a course being obtained by using a complicated scaling arrangement when combining the marks from the different parts of the course assessments together. This is too complex to try and explain here, and unhelpfully results in the whole grading process being seen as something of a black art and hence physics to be more arbitrary and complex than ought to be the case. I know that before deciding on these arrangements various modelling and piloting using different arrangements was done by SQA to ensure that almost all candidates received the same grade at the end of the new process as they would have had if the older, more simple system using half marks had been used. The need to ‘maintain standards’ lies at the heart of many of the processes used by the Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA), the Scottish Examination Board (SEB) before it, and presumably Qualifications Scotland going forward. The maintenance of standards in this way has been a strength of the Scottish system compared to that used south of the border where grade inflation was rampant for many years, although this has been addressed in more recent years. However, from my experience, the maintenance of standards can be used as an excuse to prevent change and innovation when it would be beneficial. In addition, SQA tends only to look at standards over the previous three or so years which means that there can be gradual drift over longer timescales, and there can be more radical shifts when new courses and formats of assessment are introduced such as with Higher Still and Curriculum for Excellence when year on year comparisons are harder to make. I think there has been a lack of longer-term longitudinal studies to determine how standards have shifted, as I am sure they have, albeit less than experienced in some other places.
The last piece of the puzzle is the standard of the marking, and what is deemed to be an acceptable answer to receive credit. This is more difficult to judge as the marking instructions in the public domain are somewhat sanitised versions of the operational documents. That said, it is my professional judgement that these have not changed significantly. There has also been continuity in many of the key personnel involved, for example, since the early-1990s there have only been three SEB/SQA staff with responsibility for physics. This suggests changes will have been slight and very gradual.
For the reasons described above, I do not think the difficulty of the Higher Physics examinations has drifted much, and perhaps not as much as in some other subjects. I think that this can be evidenced by two other sets of data produced by SQA. Firstly, the thresholds of attainment, i.e., the cut-off scores, for obtaining grades have changed. Twenty-five or so years ago, the score for obtaining an A grade in Higher physics was frequently 76-80%, which was a concern when the nominal score was 70%. This was necessary to ensure similar proportions of pupils obtained the same grades each year – SQA ‘maintaining standards’. I was party to many discussions about how to set papers which were accessible enough to allow enough people to pass but contained hard enough questions to prevent too many A grades without a ridiculously high threshold. This is not the case now. The threshold for obtaining an A grade is now consistently at 70% or even lower, and for a C grade usually well below 50%. If the exams are of a similar standard to before, fewer pupils are now attaining high marks.
Secondly, SQA has compared the ‘difficulty level’ of the examinations in different subjects to determine a National Rating for each subject at each level each year. This compares the results obtained by pupils studying different subjects and helps address the issue that different subjects attract different cohorts of pupils. The average difficulty level gives a National Rating of zero, ‘easier’ subjects a positive rating, and ‘more difficult’ a negative rating. In the 1990s, Higher Physics typically had one of the most negative National Ratings of all subjects; typically, around –0.3. This meant that pupils sitting Higher physics scored about one third of a grade lower than the average for all Highers. Across all the STEM subjects at all the levels there was nevertheless a mix of National Ratings with some being positive. Now the STEM subjects at all levels generally have negative National Ratings, often significantly so, and Higher Physics is typically –0.6 or more, twice as ‘difficult’ in comparative terms as before. An unfortunate side effect of a negative National Rating, given how the success of schools is measured, and the accountability pressures schools and headteachers find themselves under, is that some pupils may be guided away from studying such subjects regardless of whether this is in the best interest of either the pupils or the nation as a whole.
I think these two pieces of data show two things. First, pupils are now performing more poorly in physics, and the STEM subjects more broadly, compared to other subjects than historically was the case, and second, pupils are now performing more poorly, especially as far as top grades are concerned, than pupils in the past.
Inevitably, the explanation for this is complex and not due to a single cause. It may well be that the standards and expectations of physics examinations have changed less than other subjects. Better longitudinal research and data is required to determine if this is the case. It may well be that pupils have been prepared less well for examinations than in the past. Performance in Highers is an indicator of how well the system as a whole prepares pupils, not just what happens in the Senior Phase in secondary schools. The steady decline of Scotland in PISA assessment in reading, mathematics and science indicates that our 15-year-olds are likely less well prepared for the demands of Senior Phase courses like Higher Physics than was previously the case. Performance in the PISA science assessments for the uppermost decile of Scottish pupils has also been declining since 2006. Unfortunately, we have little or no other reliable or valid data on which to gauge performance or trends.
The Case for Change report of the Curriculum Improvement Cycle, together with international evidence, indicates the need for a better knowledge-based curriculum in the Broad General Education (BGE) phase of Scottish education. A well-designed knowledge-based, skills-oriented curriculum will help young people develop the schema and conceptual understanding necessary to tackle the higher-order thinking skills required by examinations like Higher Physics. The detailed specificity of the ambitious curricula used in high performing and improving jurisdictions such as Singapore, Alberta and Estonia compared to the short and vague statements in those such as Scotland, Finland and Australia which have seen declines in PISA scores is remarkable.
More specific to physics, the move away from the core plus extension, applications-based approach of Standard Grade Physics to the poorly articulated, less applications-based National 4 and 5 Physics courses has impacted on uptake and continuation rates from level 5 courses on to Higher. In the 1990s, Higher Physics was typically the third most popular subject after English and mathematics, but it has now dropped to eighth, with a continuing significant gender disparity. This is partly due to the rise of newer subjects such as PE, but the record of physics still fairs poorly against most other more traditional subjects, apart from languages such as French and German. The double whammy of pupils less well prepared to experience success in the subject, together with a vision of the subject which does not show how it might address the needs of society as perhaps was the case with Standard Grade Physics, is not a recipe for growth in uptake; an unfortunate result when demand for physics knowledge and skills runs high.
The current Curriculum Improvement Cycle gives Scottish education an opportunity to address the issues I have discussed above, both in terms of introducing a knowledge-based curriculum across BGE which is more ambitious in preparing pupils for later study, and by addressing shortcomings in the current national assessments. This needs to start early with improved, evidence-based approaches to teaching reading and mathematics from the early years together with the development of a coherent core curriculum through BGE which enables our young people to develop a wide vocabulary and an understanding of the key enabling concepts and practices which best enable further learning. This is not something that Curriculum for Excellence prioritised, which unfortunately left much for time-poor teachers to try and work out and develop for themselves with little or no support.
A common theme across high-performing jurisdictions is the presence of clearly specified curricula which set out learning progression, and which free teachers up to use their precious time to concentrate on how to teach it well and how to best support their learners. Scottish education can learn much by looking outwards, something we have not always done well. We also need to ensure that the curriculum architecture in the middle years of secondary education does not overly restrict the breadth of study for pupils or continue to promote the ‘two-term dash’ we have consistently failed to address since Professor John Howie was first tasked with resolving the issue in the early-1990s. We must also ensure that assessment practices are fair and appropriate and do not unnecessarily reinforce the stereotypical views many hold about the difficulty of different subjects. There is a wealth of knowledge about what works, used to work better, or does not work in the Scottish education system as well as many lessons that can be learned from other jurisdictions. We need to make some brave decisions, but the futures of our young people and our nation deserve nothing less.
Stuart Farmer is the Education and Workforce Manager at the Institute of Physics in Scotland and an Associate Fellow at the University of Stirling Centre for Research into Curriculum Making

1 comment
Andrew Bailey
The thought of options for questions in the exams is appealing to me. Often our papers are longer than necessary with University ones being shorter than the current AH one. Options wouldn’t necessarily mean the content was optional just could be more specialism.
I do feel we need to address the difficult of physics with respect to other qualifications. I’d prefer 45% for a D and 50% for a C rather than the lower values that can occur. It would be nice for pupils to experience success and gain confidence that was a benefit of the Standard Grade system where 70% in general paper led to confidence whereas now we only have the 40% in the N5 exam.