In 2024, Scotland incorporated the right of children and young people to “participate in decisions which affect them”, as is central to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. This resulted in the Youth Voice initiative to encourage “structures within which decisions are made” to “enable young people to be heard and take an active role in their own lives and communities”.
It is right to enable young people to consider their views, and build confidence by learning how to present them. Views may be gathered in response to consultation calls by public bodies through to Youth Parliaments aiming to inform pre-election manifestos, and may be presented during events. But how does the UK brief its civil and public servants, including in the NHS, so that views offered by the public are listened to, with constructive suggestions noted, and then acted upon even if at a later stage? This is a key question if Youth Voice is to avoid giving young citizens an early lesson in the frustrating fruitlessness of volunteering opinions.
Will recipients in publicly-funded bodies, including in the NHS and universities, be open to seeing trends reflected in young peoples’ views and insights, as these will often come from lived experiences? Will recipients learn usefully from such lived experiences and public perspectives, stemming wasted resource by matching services better to latest external trends and practicalities? And will recipients have open minds to the needs of others? An example of common need is to have better chance of being economically independent after school, college or university. Chances are curbed by many families, schools and careers services, who can be unable to ensure that young people even meet those who sell products and services. So whole sectors can remain out of reach, and careers denied. This includes apprenticeships in the sectors of energy, civil engineering and construction, large-scale event management, waste management, estate management, and online marketing and sales.
Youth Voice encouraging in-person “Meet the Large-Scale Employers” events could well open horizons and pathways to paid livelihoods. Such events could deepen schemes to develop the young workforce and provide information on job vacancies. They could usefully inform young people, and their families and educators, as many can be unaware of the very broad range of jobs which will be available, even with technology leaping forward. In-person “Meet the Large-Scale Employers” events would also be fair, in enabling young people to make more informed choices on study subjects, and on apprenticeship options so that they may earn as they learn, thereby avoid being saddled with long-term debt.
Does Youth Voice brief young citizens on the challenges that can be caused by powerful vested interests, whether through an industry’s aim to rig high prices or an over-riding focus by charities and quangos in securing public contracts or bigger budgets? This is a key lesson, as vested interests can be a block on simple services. For example, input from “advocacy” providers can over-complicate guidance for the public, while omitting the clear offering of self-management tips so that people may better know how to avoid confusion and crises, including hard times spent in hospital Accident and Emergency areas.
And does Youth Voice highlight feedback on how views provided did actually influence communities? For example, one city authority notes constructive suggestions (made in local place plans or community action plans) for neighbourhoods outside the authority’s current redevelopment focus. This gives the satisfaction, at least in enabling small suggestions from non-focus places to be slipped into large-scale funding proposals for neighbourhoods of current focus.
Lastly, does Youth Voice, at local authority level, significantly increase its positive impact by collaborating with public libraries and local community development trusts to maximise presentation of anonymised views of younger people? This is crucial so that more older people may learn how better to help ease the way for future generations.
Ro Pengelly draws on her experience in gathering and presenting views of employers in small firms, and of individuals, patients and unpaid carers, to public bodies widely. Her interest in meeting people from across sectors was required when she worked in commercial software services and publishing, and continues in her retirement.
